Why I don't guarantee press coverage

Years ago, I worked at a PR firm that was promising new clients the world. Guaranteed coverage. Big titles. Every month.

I remember sitting there thinking, how? We didn't own those newspapers. We didn't decide what went on the front of a magazine or which guest got booked on a breakfast show. So I asked the owner. How can we promise that?

She said: "We'll worry about that once the dotted line is signed."

I was genuinely blown away. Not because I was naive about sales, but because she said it so casually. As if the client's money, and their trust, was the finish line rather than the start.

And it didn't stop at the sales pitch. Once a contract was signed, the pressure landed on the team. If a client with no real story didn't get press, it was treated as our failure. People were screamed at. I saw colleagues crying at lunch. Getting coverage for someone with nothing to say is close to impossible, but the blame never went back to the promise that had been made. It went to the people trying to keep it.

It was a grotesque atmosphere. The greed behind those promises didn't just cost clients money. It made good people feel they were bad at their jobs.

That conversation is a big part of why I don't guarantee press coverage for my clients. Here's why, and why you should be wary of anyone who does.

This isn't me saying don't hire an agency, or that I'm the only one doing it properly. I've worked with brilliant PR firms. I recommend them, and I still work alongside them today, often paired with an agency on a client's case. There are a lot of great agencies and PR people out there.

There are also plenty of bad ones, and some are verging on scamming people. I've seen it from both sides: I've worked inside PR firms, and before I set up on my own I was the client, working in-house at businesses that paid outside agencies for coverage. So this is just honest advice. Be suspicious of any Google ad with "guaranteed press" written all over it. If it sounds too good to be true, it is.

And for me, promising you something I can't deliver would be dishonest.

How guaranteed press gets sold

Search "guaranteed PR" and you'll find packages that read like a phone contract. A set number of placements, a monthly fee, a minimum term.

A few real examples I found while writing this:

  • A music PR package charges $1,499 a month for four "guaranteed press placements", rising to $4,999 a month for eight. The four placements come with "25K+ combined readership". Not per piece. Combined.

  • A digital PR firm offers 70 placements over 12 months at $2,997 a month, with two months free if you pay ten upfront. The page says the package commits you to the full term.

  • A wholesale platform sells placements across "1,400+ owner-operated publications" from $150 each. It's pitched at agencies, who are encouraged to resell those placements to their own clients for $300 to $500, with margins of 80 to 180%.

That last one is worth sitting with. The "guaranteed press" an agency sells you could have been bought wholesale for $150, from a site you've never heard of, and marked up.

How press wires work, and the "As seen on" trick

A press wire is a paid service that sends out your press release. You pay, they publish it, and it's automatically copied onto hundreds of websites: finance portals, news aggregators and the websites of local TV stations.

It's cheap. Some wires start at $29 a release. One well-known one starts at about $100. On one freelance marketplace, $105 gets your release onto 300 to 500 news sites and lets you claim "As Seen On" FOX, NBC, CBS and ABC, because it lands on the websites of their local affiliates.

Here's the thing. Nobody at NBC, CBS or FOX read it. Nobody chose it. It's an automated feed, and those pages often carry a note saying the outlet wasn't involved in creating the content. But it still counts as a "placement" in a report, and it still gets turned into a row of shiny logos on a website.

Now put that next to a monthly retainer. If you're paying an agency £1,500 a month and your "coverage" is a wire release and a handful of cheap placements, they may have spent well under £100 on it. The rest is margin.

Press wires aren't useless. Listed companies use them for official announcements, and they can get information out quickly. The problem is when they're sold to you as press coverage. They're not. They're a paid noticeboard.

I do use them myself, but rarely, and never as a stand-in for coverage. The main reason is search. When a client's Google results or Google News are full of something inaccurate or out of date, a wire release can get accurate information indexed quickly: a correction, an official statement, or a legal outcome like a case being dropped. It puts the client's side on record with a date on it, gives journalists something to reference, and starts to rebalance what people see when they search the name.

When I do it, the client knows exactly what it is. A way of making the facts findable, not a piece of press.

Read the small print

The word "guaranteed" does a lot of work in these packages. The detail underneath it usually does a lot less.

What counts as a placement. One package lists "blog features, magazine articles, interview write-ups, and editorial mentions". Another counts "an expert-comment mention, or inclusion in a roundup". So a single line about you in a listicle can tick the box, the same as a full interview.

What happens if they miss. This is where it gets interesting. The monthly packages I looked at don't mention giving your money back if the numbers aren't hit. The promise is that they'll keep working "at no additional cost until we deliver", or keep pitching "with a new angle until it does". In other words, you've already paid, and the remedy is more of the same.

How long you're tied in. Three, six or twelve months, often with a discount for paying upfront. Long enough that by the time you realise the coverage isn't what you pictured, you're halfway through the contract.

Even people in the industry who defend guaranteed coverage admit there's a gap between predicting coverage and promising it. A big news event can wipe a story off the schedule overnight, and no contract changes that.

The clever workarounds

When an agency has promised a number it can't hit, it has to find a way to hit it. Some of the ways I've come across:

  • Wire pickups counted as coverage. One release goes out on a press wire, gets copied onto 200 sites, and suddenly your report can say you've had 200 pieces of coverage.

  • Cheap placements on sites nobody reads. Bought in bulk, marked up, and listed next to real titles as if they were the same thing.

  • Roundups and passing mentions. One line about you in a "top 50" list, counted the same as a feature interview.

  • The agency's own website. I've had clients come to me completely convinced that a firm they'd hired before simply set up its own "news" blog and published their stories on it. That counted as coverage. Nobody reads a site like that. It doesn't rank on Google and it doesn't get seen. It's a complete waste of money.

None of these are illegal on their own. But none of them are press coverage either, and if you're paying for press coverage, you deserve to know the difference.

Why it can't work

The problem is simple. PR people don't publish anything. Journalists, editors and producers do.

I can find your story, shape it, pitch it to the right person at the right time and make sure you're ready when they call. What I can't do is decide what goes in their paper. Nobody outside that newsroom can. Promising coverage is promising what a third party will do, and they haven't signed anything.

Even knowing a journalist personally doesn't change that. At one agency I worked at, the owner had one journalist friend she leaned on heavily to get clients into the paper. And even he couldn't always do it. Journalists have editors, and editors have bosses. A story still has to get the green light, and being friends with the PR person isn't a reason to run it.

Working in PR doesn't come with a supply of articles you can hand out. Anyone who talks as if it does is either exaggerating or cutting corners somewhere.

The Times put it bluntly: if an agency tells you it can guarantee coverage, it's "a totally false claim".

Journalists also need something to work with. A real story. New information. An opinion worth hearing. Access, timing, a reason their readers should care. If there's genuinely nothing new to say, no amount of pitching changes that. I'm not going to pretend otherwise and send you an invoice for trying.

I'm honest with clients about this from the first call. I've had founders in tech walk me through what they want to push, and I've had to tell them, kindly, that it's a bit boring. Usually we both end up laughing, because they know it too. That's fine. It just means we aim at the specialist publications that genuinely care about that subject, and that coverage often works far better for them than a national would, because it reaches exactly the people they want to reach.

What I can't do is turn nothing into the Financial Times. I get a lot of businesses asking if I can get them into the FT or Forbes, and when I ask what the story is, there isn't one yet. No news, no data, no strong opinion, nothing a journalist could build a piece around. My honest answer is: what would I pitch?

What I'll do is tell you honestly whether there's a story, help you find it if it's hiding, and be straight with you if it isn't there yet.

What chasing a number does to you

When an agency has promised eight placements a month, it has to find eight placements a month. Whether they're any good is a separate question.

So you end up on sites nobody reads, in roundups that mention you in passing, or on pages that exist mainly to sell space. One industry commentator described a guaranteed placement as something "arranged with the outlet rather than independently pursued by a journalist". That's the difference. Real coverage happens because a journalist decided you were worth writing about. Readers can usually tell.

If money changes hands for that space, it's advertising. In the UK, the advertising code says paid content has to be obviously identifiable as an ad, with labels like "Advertisement Feature". So either it's labelled, and readers know it's an ad, or it isn't, and that's a problem of its own.

There's a reputational cost too. Your name ends up next to junk. And journalists who get spammed with weak pitches from the same agency start ignoring it, which makes it harder to get you real coverage when you actually need it.

What I do instead

I don't sell a number. I tell you at the start what I think is realistic, based on what you've actually got to say, and then I go after the coverage that's worth having.

That means finding the real story, pitching it to journalists who cover your world, and preparing you properly when they say yes. It also means telling you when an opportunity isn't right, and being honest when there isn't enough there yet. As the work goes on, we look at what the coverage is doing for you, not how many times your name appeared.

I'd much rather work with you to build a genuinely good story, be realistic about where it could land, and work out the best route to real press that's actually useful to you. One piece in the right publication will do more for you than fifty you'd be embarrassed to send anyone.

If you're talking to any PR agency, including me, ask these before you sign:

  1. What exactly counts as a placement?

  2. Which outlets are we talking about, and are any of them paid or sponsored?

  3. Will any of it be press wire pickups, or sites you own or run?

  4. What happens if you don't hit the number? Do I get money back?

  5. How long am I tied in, and can I leave?

  6. Who will actually be pitching my story?

If the answers are vague, or the plan is to worry about it once the dotted line is signed, you have your answer.

Previous
Previous

How to respond to a bad review when you’d quite like to argue with the customer

Next
Next

Jensen Huang's apology: what the Nvidia crisis teaches us about saying sorry