How to respond to a bad review when you’d quite like to argue with the customer

One of my favourite things to stumble across on Google is a business owner arguing with someone who’s left them a bad review. I’m particularly fond of the ones where the customer says the owner was rude and the owner replies at some length to explain what an absolute idiot the customer is. Up until then, I was prepared to hear both sides. Now I’ve seen how you speak to people when you’ve had time to sit down, type it out and check the spelling. Goodness knows what you said in person.

You only went on Google to see whether a café does lunch on Sundays. Ten minutes later, you’re reading about a jacket potato that was apparently stone cold. According to the owner, it was perfectly hot when it arrived, but the customer spent five minutes filming it for a vlog and another ten outside chatting to a friend. By this point I feel personally involved. I want to know how long she was outside, whether the butter melted and who’s telling the truth about this jacket potato.

The awkward thing is, I quite often believe the owner. Fifteen minutes sounds like a perfectly reasonable explanation for a cold potato. It’s when he carries on to tell us what he thought of the woman personally that he loses me. I believe him about the lunch. I also think he sounds rude, and now I’d sooner eat somewhere else. That’s the catch-22. He’s convinced me he was right and talked me out of visiting his café in the same paragraph.

It’s one of the reasons I think online reviews can be unfair, particularly for small businesses. With local word of mouth, you know who’s telling you the story. If a friend whose judgement I trust says someone was rude to her, I’ll take that seriously. If it’s the neighbour who’s fallen out with every tradesperson on our street, I can allow for the possibility that the plumber was having a perfectly nice morning until he got to her house.

Online, you have no idea who’s behind the one star. It could be a customer who had an awful experience, a competitor pretending to be one or someone who’s simply after a bloody refund. A negative review gives that last person a fairly easy way to put pressure on a business. The owner knows the customer has offered to take it down in exchange for compensation. The person looking for lunch sees one star and a story about a potato.

Meanwhile, the people who enjoyed their lunch thanked the staff and went home. I’m exactly the same. I’m in hotels a hell of a lot and, as far as I can remember, I’ve left precisely one review in my life. I can stay somewhere lovely, recommend it to friends and book it again myself without once thinking to tell Google. Sandals Grande Antigua, on the other hand, managed to annoy me so much that I created a Tripadvisor account specifically to review it. Having to come up with a password would normally be enough for me to abandon the whole thing.

The one time I felt obliged to leave a bad review

We’d had a pretty rough 2022, so we treated ourselves to a week in Antigua over Christmas. We wanted to relax, feel a little spoilt and start 2023 in a better frame of mind. Sandals is such a well-known name and, given how much we were paying per night, we thought we were in for a lovely week. We booked the best room the hotel offered without “butler service”. As we understood it, we’d booked the same type of room as guests who’d opted for a butler. The only extra we’d declined was the butler himself.

Frankly, the idea made us both cringe a bit. Who did we think we were, needing someone to look after us for a week at an all-inclusive resort where our only plan was to do absolutely nothing? Knowing me, I’d have got up to fetch my own drink and asked the butler if he fancied anything while I was there. I’m just not built for that sort of thing. I’d spend the week worrying about whether he was all right, which rather defeats the point. The fancy room was the treat.

Anyway, since absolutely nobody asked, let me tell you about this holiday. We landed in Antigua and waited nearly an hour in the airport carpark for what was supposed to be Sandals’ fancy pick-up service. Eventually, a van turned up looking like it had just been in a police chase on GTA 6. We sat with our suitcases balanced on our laps, and I could feel every spring in the seat. Still, the grounds were stunning when we arrived. There were beautiful gardens, parrots and the Caribbean Sea in the background. For a moment I thought, oh, thank God, it was just the van.

We were asked to take a seat in reception while we waited to check in. We’d been sitting there for about 45 minutes when the guests who’d booked butler service pulled up in a lovely car. They were greeted with welcome drinks, checked in straight away and shown to their rooms. Once they’d gone, our drinks arrived and it was finally our turn to check in. By then we were looking at each other and laughing, wondering what on earth we’d signed up for. We were still optimistic enough to think it might just be an odd way to run reception.

What I wish they’d told us when we booked

I’ve stayed in plenty of hotels where paying extra gets you access to another pool or a private lounge. If that’s clear when you book, I think it’s perfectly fair. You can decide for yourself how strongly you feel about a second pool. What I hadn’t understood from the Sandals advertising was how much someone else having a butler would affect my holiday.

Take dinner. Guests with butlers could choose where they wanted to eat and on which night, and their butlers booked the best times in advance. The rest of us (the Sandals peasants) queued for about an hour to be handed a piece of paper telling us where and when we’d be eating. One dinner was at 4.30pm, another at 8.30pm. We explained that one of the restaurants didn’t appeal and asked whether we could move the 4.30pm booking a little later. The woman told us those were the only options.

I’d never stayed at an all-inclusive resort where I couldn’t choose where to eat, particularly one that advertised 11 restaurants. One of those “restaurants” turned out to be a hot dog stand that opened for about an hour a day, so I think we had slightly different ideas about what counted. On the nights we didn’t fancy our allocated dinner, we’d have been perfectly happy to order room service and spend the evening on our terrace. Except room service was reserved for guests with butlers. We’d paid five-star prices and somehow the most flexible dining option available to us was a hot dog, provided we caught it during opening hours.

Every morning, the butlers were out first thing reserving the best sunbeds around the pool, including all the ones with shade. We’d try the beach and find exactly the same thing. The loungers left were in blazing sunshine without an umbrella. I can’t sit in direct sun all day, so on several days we ended up paying $115 for a cabana just to have somewhere shady to sit. Even at the bar, I could be halfway through ordering a drink when a butler appeared and the bartender would turn away to take his order first. I’d been quite happy to fetch my own drinks. I’d assumed I’d at least get to finish the sentence.

Our room was at the back of the hotel, the furniture was covered in dust and there wasn’t even a dressing gown. I appreciate that a missing dressing gown in the Caribbean is a fairly first-world complaint, but at that nightly rate I’d expected one. The airport hotel we’d stayed in the night before our flight had better amenities, and we’d chosen it for its outstanding views of the departures board.

By the end of the week, it felt as though ordinary comforts had been stripped back to make the butler service worth buying. I’d have put the room and amenities at about two stars. My bank account had very much been charged for the other three.

The public review was my fourth attempt to speak to someone

I found the three emails I sent Sandals before I wrote the review. The first two were very polite. By the third, I think you could probably tell I’d been polite twice already. Working in marketing and PR, I know how damaging a public review can be, so I wanted to give them a chance to respond privately.

If they’d replied to even one of those emails and acknowledged why we felt let down, I wouldn’t have left a review. From the website, I’d understood that paying for a butler meant someone would bring you drinks and book dinner for you. It hadn’t occurred to me that booking dinner myself meant choosing from whatever the butlers had left. We’d paid five-star prices for a room with amenities I’d have expected at a two- or three-star hotel. It felt as though they’d stripped things back to make the upgrade worth buying. All I wanted was for someone to say they could see why that had come as a surprise and they were sorry it hadn’t been clearer when we booked.

Instead, all three emails went unanswered. By then I was angry about spending several thousand pounds on a disappointing holiday, and even angrier about being ignored. Rereading the review, I can see exactly where that frustration went. I covered the kettle, the Wi-Fi strength in Cabana 3 and the price of a bikini I hadn’t even bought. When I found it again, I was quite proud to see “23 helpful votes” next to my review. Given the amount of scrolling involved, anyone who made it as far as the swimwear has my thanks.

I gave them three stars in the end. It had felt like a one-star holiday, but the grounds were beautiful, the sushi was decent and I know how it feels to be on the receiving end of a one-star rating. When it came to clicking that little circle, I wanted to give them the benefit of the doubt.

I felt rather vindicated when a client later told me she’d had much the same experience with the butlers at a Sandals in Saint Lucia. I was more surprised to see guests describing similar frustrations nearly four years later. Anyway, writing about it again has felt a bit like therapy. One reply to a polite email and my findings on the kettle could have stayed between us.

Can one bad Google review cost a small business customers?

Imagine you’ve just opened a salon. Your first four customers give you five stars each. The fifth gives you one star and your rating drops from 5.0 to 4.2. Someone looking for a haircut sees a 4.8 a few doors down and books there instead. They might never read the review, and you’ll never know they were considering you. If you’re a hairdresser renting a chair, a handful of lost appointments in a quiet month could be the difference between covering the rent and having to find the money elsewhere.

That’s why I wish people would pause for a moment before clicking one star. I understand wanting to warn someone about a bad experience. I’d just ask myself whether one star is a fair account of what happened, and whether I’ve given the person running the business a chance to put it right. Sometimes a warning is entirely justified. Other times, I’m annoyed, and a conversation with the owner might leave me feeling quite differently about the whole thing.

If I’ve had a poor experience, I’ll always contact the business privately first. A public review is a last resort for me, which is why I gave Sandals three opportunities to reply. I was annoyed about something every day of that holiday and I came home feeling the advertising had given us a very different idea of what we were paying for. Even then, I gave them three stars. The grounds were beautiful, I liked the coffee shop and I wanted to give them the benefit of the doubt where I could. I knew how much that holiday had cost me. I think it’s only fair to give some thought to what a review might cost the person on the receiving end, particularly when it’s someone trying to keep a small business going.

What should you say when you reply to a bad review?

For all my reservations about leaving a bad review, I think mine was fair. I’d have been grateful to read something like it before I booked. We’d originally planned to stay at Sandals in Barbados and switched to Antigua fairly last minute. From the way Sandals described the resort, I thought we’d get the five-star, all-inclusive holiday they advertised, just without a personal butler. I was perfectly happy to make my own dinner reservations. I just didn’t expect to queue for an hour to find out they’d already been made for me.

It was only when I went back to the website afterwards that I noticed how much it said about the resort as a whole and how little it said about what came with our particular room. That vagueness felt quite deliberate to me, and that’s what annoyed me most. I knew I’d declined a butler. It hadn’t occurred to me that I needed to check whether I’d also declined room service.

There were plenty of five-star reviews, and I probably paid too little attention to how many of them mentioned a butler. If yours got you a shaded sunbed every morning and a table at your favourite restaurant every evening, I can see why you’d recommend the place. I’d assumed a butler saved you the trouble of arranging those things yourself. What I wanted the next guest to know was what happened when we tried.

That’s worth bearing in mind when you’re on the receiving end of a bad review. Some customers are trying to give someone else the information they wish they’d had before spending the money. Sandals did eventually thank me publicly for my “detailed review”, which was diplomatic given the amount of scrolling involved. But if I’d been a prospective guest reading their reply, I’d still have had one fairly straightforward question. If I book that room without a butler, how do I choose where and when I eat? A clear answer would have helped me decide whether that holiday was right for me. It might also have been worth another look at the booking page to see why I’d come away with such a different impression.

When you write your own reply, think about what the next customer needs to know. If someone says they waited an hour for a table they’d reserved, the person reading is wondering whether the same thing could happen to their booking on Saturday. If you found the error, apologised and changed how you confirm tables, say so. Nobody needs your recollection of how much prosecco the group had consumed.

For the part that’s personal to the customer, I’d follow up privately. If you have their details, email them yourself or offer to call at a time that suits them. And before you publicly invite them to get in touch, check whether they already have. Imagine how differently it would have landed if someone had said, I’ve found the three emails you sent us. I’m sorry you had to chase us. I’ve read them and I’ll call you this afternoon if that suits you. I’d have appreciated that, especially if the phone then rang.

A customer who feels heard may update their review or decide to remove it. I’d leave that decision to them. As a prospective customer, I’d find an update saying the owner rang, listened and sorted things out quite reassuring. It tells me something even a five-star review can’t always tell me. If my booking goes wrong, who’s going to pick up the phone?

How do you get happy customers to leave a review?

I visit Stockholm a hell of a lot and I’ve probably stayed at Villa Dagmar, a beautiful hotel in the city, fifteen to twenty times. I’ve never had a bad experience there. I know every room type and, when they give me my room number at check-in, I already know which part of the hotel I’m in. The beds are some of the comfiest I’ve ever slept in and they mix béchamel into their scrambled eggs, which is absolute genius. Even the porridge deserves a mention. It comes with apple and cinnamon and I couldn’t feel more Scandinavian eating it if I tried.

If I’m craving a weekend of sunshine, it’s Hotel Cappuccino in Palma for me. It’s my little escape when work’s been busy and I need a couple of days to breathe. Mention Stockholm and I’ll recommend Villa Dagmar. Tell me you need a bit of sun and I’ll send you the link to Hotel Cappuccino. They’re my two favourite hotels. Have I ever left either of them a review online? Never. I could show you to your room at Villa Dagmar and tell you what to order for breakfast on the way, yet the only hotel I’ve ever reviewed is the one with the van.

I think I owe them both a review. In my head I recommend them all the time, but that’s of little use to someone looking them up on Google. A short email after checkout with a direct link and one question would probably prompt me to do it. If a friend was thinking of staying here, what would you tell them? I know how to answer that. In Stockholm, order the eggs.

I’d send the same invitation to every guest and leave it there. By the third reminder, my relaxing weekend in Palma has somehow given me an outstanding task.

Can you get an unfair one-star review removed?

People ask me this quite often. I usually start by asking what makes the review unfair. Has a customer told their side of a disagreement and left out a detail the owner thinks matters? Or has the business been criticised online and suddenly half of TikTok appears to have had a dreadful haircut in a salon they’ve never visited? Those are two very different conversations.

Google and Trustpilot both require reviews to reflect a genuine experience, although that can happen before any money changes hands. If you ring a wedding venue and the owner is spectacularly rude to you, that conversation might be the very reason you chose to get married elsewhere. You’ve still dealt with the business. Someone who’s only seen a clip of the owner online has a harder time explaining what, exactly, they’re reviewing.

A few years back, it took six months to get a particularly unfair one-star review removed from my own business. I also discovered an unfortunate drawback to calling a PR agency Honest. Every so often, someone looking for Honest Burgers would find us instead and leave me a one-star review about their lunch. Quite funny in hindsight. Slightly less amusing when it’s your business being marked down for a burger you didn’t make.

Those experiences are part of why I wrote The Little Guide to Bad Reviews. If there’s a review on your business profile you’re unsure how to handle, I’ll walk you through when you have grounds to challenge it, what evidence to include in a removal request and what to say if it stays up. Ideally, give it a read while your reply is still in drafts.

Download The Little Guide to Bad Reviews

Next
Next

Why I don't guarantee press coverage